Explanation for Simon's disqualifying Melanie Amaro.
I was so impressed with Melanie that I had to spend a few hours overlaying Whitney. Melanie is a few milliseconds faster, so it was a pain dropping frames on Whitney here and there to try and maintain synchronization. I apologize for a few imperfections that can be heard. I'm no professional and I just used Windows Movie Maker, but I think it still turned out well enough to make the point that Melanie is another Whitney in my opinion. Update 11/19/11: Thanks for all the views and positive feedback! I'm glad everybody appreciates the video! Update 2/12/12: I'm sure everyone morns the loss of Whitney as I do. Sad Day! 
Melanie Amaro The World's Greatest The X Factor USA Top 9 Performance HQ Melanie Amaro The World's Greatest The X Factor USA Top 9 Performance HQ Melanie Amaro The World's Greatest The X Factor USA Top 9 Performance HQ
finally, now we know the winner of the x factor 2011, it's melanie amaro, all of the finalists have been great!!
Melanie Amaro performs "Listen" by Beyonce The X Factor USA the Final.
Melanie Amaro win x-Factor
I'm new in Youtube, pls Sub if u like it 
Follow me on Facebook: www.facebook.com
Disclaimer: I take no responsibility for the performance shown in this video. The performance shown is the sole property The X Factor, US THE X FACTOR ™ & ©, is a registered trademark of 2011 FremantleMedia North America, Inc. and Simco Limited. All Rights Reserved. ® and © FOX and its related entities; SyCo TV, CTV.
Disclaimer: I take no responsibility for the performance shown in this video. The performance shown is the sole property The X Factor, US THE X FACTOR ™ & ©, is a registered trademark of 2011 FremantleMedia North America, Inc. and Simco Limited. All Rights Reserved. ® and © FOX and its related entities; SyCo TV, CTV. Melanie sings her rendition of Michael Jackson's 'What About Us'.
Melanie Amaro performs "Someone Like You" by Adele. Melanie Amaro performs "When You Believe" by Prince of Egypt www.thexfactorusa.com bit.ly (Official Site) bit.ly ('Like' on Facebook) bit.ly (Follow on Twitter) Josh Krajcik - We Found Love / Something Chris Rene - Where Do We Go From Here? / Live Your Life Melanie Amaro - When You Believe / Someone Like You Rachel Crow - Nothin' On You / Music And Me Marcus Canty - Ain't Nobody / A Song For You